TechServ Logo

Overhead vs. Underground Distribution for New Utilities

overhead distribution lines for power and utilities
Choosing overhead or underground distribution depends on many factors, including utility type and project location.

When designing the layout for a new electric distribution system, providers must decide whether to use underground distribution or overhead distribution lines. There are advantages and disadvantages to each approach, and the best strategy will vary for different utilities and locations. 

In this blog, we will break down the benefits and disadvantages of both methods. No matter which you choose, TechServ is here to help you with the planning and construction of both types of distribution systems. Contact us for assistance.

Benefits of Overhead Distribution

Overhead distribution lines are the traditional power lines strung between utility poles. This is the most common method of power distribution for a number of reasons:

  • Cost: Overhead line installation is significantly less expensive than underground distribution, especially for initial construction.
  • Ease of Maintenance: Overhead lines offer greater visibility and accessibility, which can make repairs and maintenance faster and simpler.
  • Flexibility: Overhead distribution systems are often easier to modify or add capacity to as demand changes.

Disadvantages of Overhead Distribution

  • Vulnerable to Weather: Storms, high winds, falling trees, and even heavy ice buildup can cause extensive damage to overhead lines, resulting in power outages.
  • Aesthetic Impact: Some communities find overhead lines unsightly and argue they can impact property values.
  • Safety Considerations: Overhead lines pose electrocution risks, especially when downed by weather events or accidents.

Benefits of Underground Distribution

With underground distribution, lines are buried in trenches below the ground. This approach offers specific benefits:

  • Enhanced Reliability: Underground lines are remarkably less vulnerable to weather-related incidents and outages. They are protected against wind, ice, and falling debris.
  • Aesthetics: Many prefer the visual appeal of underground distribution, as it eliminates the clutter of overhead lines.
  • Reduced Safety Risks: Underground distribution lines significantly minimize electrocution risks from downed lines.

Disadvantages of Underground Distribution

  • Substantially Higher Cost: The initial installation cost for an underground distribution system is significantly higher than overhead systems. Trenching, installation of specialized equipment, and the added materials come with a hefty price tag.
  • Increased Repair Complexity: Diagnosing and repairing problems with underground lines can be more time-consuming and expensive.
  • Environmental Impact: Trenching associated with underground lines can lead to potential issues of soil disruption and concerns during construction.

Which is Better for New Utilities?

There is no correct choice between underground and overhead distribution. Each utility provider must make a multi-faceted decision. It’s important to consider community standards, as some local governments have regulations dictating whether utilities should be overhead or underground. Long-term planning should also be considered, as underground lines tend to have a longer lifespan and require less maintenance, which may offset the higher initial costs. Lastly, utility providers should consider the terrain. Challenging terrain can increase the cost and complexities of underground installation.

The decision between underground distribution and overhead distribution is critical for the efficiency and longevity of a utility system. Carefully weighing the various costs, benefits, and local considerations is crucial to making the optimal choice for new utility setups.

For help regarding utility distribution planning and construction, contact us today!

Spark Your Career
Partner With Us